The Impact of Casuals on the WNBA and It’s Community

As the WNBA season marches on, we find ourselves at the end of an Olympic break—I can't help but wonder why it's been so quiet lately, and I think I know why. Caitlin Clark didn't play in the Olympic Games, so her fans decided not to show up and cheer on Team USA. If we look back a few weeks ago, her casual fans threatened to boycott the Olympic Games in protest of her not making the team. While they believe they taught the WNBA, Dawn Staley, and the Olympic committee a lesson, die-hard fans had the opportunity to focus on Team USA, cheer them on as they won their gold, and also criticize the game appropriately without raging casuals trying to center the entire game of women’s basketball around Clark or Angel Reese, the one they’ve deemed her arch-nemesis.

Clark’s fans have taken the art of being a casual sports fan to a whole new level. They aren’t just occasional viewers who enjoy the game without digging into the details. They are hyper-focused on a single player and, by extension, a single team—the Indiana Fever—while strategically ignoring everything else happening in the league. Their fandom is so narrowly focused that they often miss the broader context of the game, the league’s nuances, and the incredible performances of other players who deserve attention and respect.

The Problem with Single-Player Fandom

Focusing on one player isn’t inherently bad, but when it comes with a barrage of complaints about officiating, league management, and the performance of other players, it starts to look like a problem. These fans show up in full force only when it’s time to defend Clark or to bash Reese, but where are they when the league’s top players are putting on a show? Where’s the love for WNBA champions and All-Stars who have been carrying the league on their backs?

The problem is that this kind of narrow-minded fandom creates a toxic environment where only certain players are elevated while others are unjustly ignored or criticized. Take, for example, the bizarre pride Clark fans have in defending Kate Martin, a player who averages just three points per game, yet casual fans attempted to vote her into the All-Star game. It’s not about disliking Martin—she’s a fine player in her own right—but the comparison speaks volumes. Why is so much energy devoted to players who contribute so little on the court while established stars are overlooked?

Advertisement

This selective support isn’t just annoying; it’s dismissive. It warps the conversation around the WNBA, turning it into a battleground of personal loyalties rather than a celebration of the sport. When casual fans show up only to defend one player, they diminish the achievements of others. They ignore the hard work, talent, and dedication of players who have been grinding all season, just because they don’t fit into their narrow view of what the league should be.

The Consequences of Casual Fandom

This kind of fandom is also unfair to the league as a whole. When fans only pay attention to one player, they miss out on the richness of the league and contribute to a skewed narrative that doesn’t reflect the true diversity and talent on display.

It’s also worth noting that these casual fans, who are so quick to complain about officiating and league decisions, were nowhere to be found when Team USA was bringing home the gold. If you’re not showing up to cheer on the national team, are you really a fan of the sport? Or are you just here for the drama?

Where Do We Go from Here?

So, should we ignore these casual fans as they’ve ignored the broader game of basketball? Should die-hard fans continue to report on the league with nuance and fairness, even when it feels like their voices are being drowned out by casuals who only want to rage-bait and bully online? The answer isn’t simple.

On one hand, we need to keep the conversation going for the sake of the league and its players. The WNBA deserves fair coverage that highlights the achievements of all its stars, not just the ones who have the most vocal fans. But on the other hand, maybe it’s time to stop giving so much attention to those who only want to participate in the conversation when it suits their agenda. Maybe it’s time to let their voices fade into the background, just as they have done during this Olympic break.

At the end of the day, the WNBA is bigger than any one player, and it’s certainly bigger than the casual fans who only show up when they have something to complain about. So, here’s a question for those fans: Are you in it for the love of the game, or just for the spectacle? Because the league—and the die-hard fans who support it—deserve better.